The EVC MagazineSign in
Headline supportersExperience EducationHalsbury TravelPGLAll supporters
← Features
Students locked in debate. Kenilworth School and Sixth Form
Feature

A 'knock-out' experience for young debaters

Nikki Kennedy

By Nikki Kennedy, Head of Marketing and Communications- EVOLVE Advice · 19 Oct 2026 · 9 min read

The EVC Magazine attended the KMAT Great Debate at Kenilworth School and Sixth Form in October to see how this novel experience was shaping the world of school debating for young people today.

If you think you know debating, think again. The KMAT Great Debate is the brainchild of Aaron Dudley a teacher and Head of Year 11 at Kenilworth School and Sixth Form. Mr Dudley describes it as “debate boxing” and it certainly felt like that.

It was a grey day in October but the atmosphere inside the room was electric, with smoke machines and loud music creating a buzz for contestants, spectators and judges alike. The excited debaters poured into the room to the sound of Eye of the Tiger accompanied by whoops and cheers from their schoolmates and settled themselves in for the first round of debating.

This is the third year that Kenilworth School and Sixth Form has run its Great Debate, and it continues to expand its reach within and beyond Warwickshire. The aim of the competition is to develop oracy, critical thinking and communication skills – important skills for life. It also helps build confidence, requiring them to form and justify opinions on some of the most important issues of the day.

From just seven schools taking part in its first iteration, this year’s Great Debate saw applications from over forty schools from across and beyond Warwickshire.

12 teams competed in this, the final of the Great Debate and the stakes were high. Each team was made-up of up to eight debaters who took it in turns to participate in knockout rounds judged by local dignitaries and business people. Debates took place simultaneously with up to 24 happening at one time.

“The tension in the air there was practically electric, and there was a sense of anticipation right before every match.” (Easa, Year 8, Lawrence Sheriff School)

Lawrence Sheriff School in Rugby took home the winners trophy and one of its team, Toby was also awarded Humanitarian Debater by the British Red Cross. This category required students to demonstrate the values of kindness and compassion when debating the statement: ‘Communities should be expected to prepare for emergencies rather than relying solely on emergency services’.

"From the moment I walked in, to the moment I left, the KMAT Great Debate was such an amazing experience. I loved the way Kenilworth School went all out; with the smoke machines, crazy lights and music, it almost felt like a concert. Debating in this environment against lots of different people from all sorts of schools was just magical and I was so proud of LSS when we won. I think we all did incredibly well and worked really hard, so it was well deserved by all of us and all the other schools we competed against did such a good job too.
"I am also incredibly chuffed with myself and thank you to the Red Cross for awarding me with the Humanitarian Debater Award. All in all, I thought it was a super experience that was really good for boosting confidence in public speaking and self-esteem. Thank you KMAT." - Toby C, Year 8

Mairi Allan, Head of Youth at the British Red Cross said:

“It was fantastic to see young people engaging in humanitarian topics, understanding the complexities involved and building their own confidence and skills to stand up for humanity.”

As the day went on, the pressure increased, and the tension in the room was palpable. Team members gathered around their colleagues helping them to prepare and giving encouragement before the debate began. After that they were on their own, head-to-head with a student from another school and watched closely by a panel of judges scoring them on the content and delivery of their debate.

"The KMAT Debate was a really fun experience, a wonderful chance to compete and battle against other schools in unique ways. The tension in the air there was practically electric, and there was a sense of anticipation right before every match. Winning an individual award was likely the best part, a great memoir for a fantastic debate.” – Easa K, Year 8

A hush settled over the room as the final began, enabling everyone to hear an outstanding debate between the two finalists Eleanor and Eliza. Each demonstrated a confidence and clarity rarely found in the boardroom, let alone the classroom. They debated whether university was the best route to a successful career with key arguments covering apprenticeships, student debt, and the value of higher education.

The award for best individual debater went to Eleanor of Stratford Girls’ Grammar School. Students were judged on their articulate presentation of the facts and their use of vocabulary; whether or not they agreed with the position was irrelevant. They were expected to deliver an argument respectfully and convincingly with just 5 minutes preparation time on one of 10 potential topics.

Eleanor, best individual debater. Kenilworth School and Sixth Form
SponsoredEVOLVE Advice

Advertising keeps The EVC Magazine free. Find out more

The BIG questions

Perhaps the most revealing moments came after the formal contests. Students whose teams had been eliminated offered their research and expertise to competitors who had defeated them in earlier rounds. Such generosity demonstrated the spirit at the heart of the competition: the ability to challenge an opponent robustly, listen carefully and then help that same person succeed.

The EVC Magazine’s Nikki Kennedy was a judge at the debate.

“Judging the debate was both challenging and an honour,” she said.
“I was hugely impressed by the debaters and by way the young people worked together as a team. The KMAT great debate is a brilliant example of learning outside the classroom. It brings together pupils from different schools and settings, giving them an opportunity to apply their learning and develop skills for life.”

As Mr Dudley described the participants in his opening speech, these young people may not always be the most visible students in the classroom, but this competition really plays to their strengths. These are the students with deep love of knowledge and a passion for debating and this is their moment to shine.

The Great Debate will be back next year and is already in talks with organisations beyond the region to give more young people access to this unique opportunity. Watch this space!

“Debating in this environment against lots of different people from all sorts of schools was just magical and I was so proud of LSS when we won” - Toby, Year 8, Lawrence Sheriff School
"Events, like the KMAT Great Debate, offer students a fantastic opportunity to develop their skills of listening and response, research and critical thinking. It was wonderful to see the students rise to the challenge!" - Beth Mason, Head of Citizenship, Teacher of History, Politics and RP at Lawrence Sheriff School.
Nikki Kennedy

Nikki Kennedy

Head of Marketing and Communications- EVOLVE Advice

Find out more

SponsoredEVOLVE Advice

Advertising keeps The EVC Magazine free. Find out more

Got a story or a tip to share?

Other EVCs and Visit Leaders want to hear it.

Read the whole magazine, free

Sign in with your email, or download our free app for editions, news and offline reading.

More to read